AOC Discovers the Horrors of Civil Asset Forfeiture, Rails Against the Practice in Congressional Hearing

America’s civil asset forfeiture system is unfair, un-American, and ripe for reform—and people are finally beginning to notice.
Saturday, December 11, 2021

Image Credit: nrkbeta,-Wiki Commons| CC BY-SA 2.0
Brad Polumbo
Brad Polumbo
Politics AOC Civil Asset Forfeiture Theft Criminal Justice Police Justice Social Justice
Leer en Español
facebook sharing buttontwitter sharing buttonflipboard sharing buttonreddit sharing buttonlinkedin sharing buttonemail sharing button
Far-left Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez is right about something. Yes, you read that correctly.

During a Wednesday House hearing, the New York congresswoman gave impassioned remarks railing against “civil asset forfeiture.” This refers to various federal and local law enforcement practices wherein private citizens’ assets — such as cash, cars, or homes — are confiscated due to the mere suspicion they’re associated with criminal activity. Often this occurs without much due process at all.

Some of the framing here is a bit unnecessarily woke, but what @AOC says here about civil asset forfeiture is absolutely correct. It’s a vile, unamerican practice and Dems & Republicans should come together to end it. https://t.co/Go715oIUfc

— Brad Polumbo 🇺🇸⚽️ 🏳️‍🌈 (@brad_polumbo) December 9, 2021
“This is an issue that so many people in this country cannot believe is real,” Ocasio-Cortez said . “Civil forfeiture means that the government, law enforcement, etc., is allowed to take away your property — often your car or even your home — without an arrest, without criminal charges, and without ever going to court. And then the police can sell your property and use the proceeds as revenue.”

Ocasio-Cortez has identified a very real problem. Over the last 20 years, the government has confiscated roughly $68.8 billion in property through this unfair process, according to the Institute for Justice. And, as the below graph shows, in 2019, the federal government alone — not even counting state and local law enforcement — stole more property annually than burglars did!

Today I learned that federal law enforcement steals more from Americans than burglars… pic.twitter.com/4NArVhQVjJ

— Brad Polumbo 🇺🇸⚽️ 🏳️‍🌈 (@brad_polumbo) December 9, 2021
And don’t make the mistake of thinking that most of this property is confiscated from convicted criminals or known leaders of drug cartels. As the congresswoman notes, it’s often taken without charges or a trial, and most of it is taken from very small-time offenders. Sometimes, the property taken is not owned by the person suspected of a crime, just by someone associated with a suspect, like the mother of a suspect.

Here are some examples of everyday victims of civil asset forfeiture, as I reported for the Dispatch in 2020:

1. [Isiah] Kinloch fought off a burglar who tried to break into his apartment. When he called the police, officers found a small amount of marijuana in the apartment and, without any evidence of a connection, seized $1,800 in cash they found in the home. Drug charges were filed against Kinloch but later dropped, and he was never convicted of any crime. Police kept the cash.

2. A taco truck driver had $10,000 seized by the Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department even though he was never arrested or charged with a crime. He was never able to recover the funds.

These are the kinds of victims Ocasio-Cortez was talking about. The congresswoman went on to say that under this forfeiture system, “it’s disproportionately poor people, low-income people, and people of color who are having their property seized.”

While the real issue is the inherent unfairness of this practice for anyone, Ocasio-Cortez still may be right about the existence of disparities. In South Carolina, for example, the Greenville News reports : “Seven out of 10 people who have property taken are black, and 65% of all money police seize is from black males.” On the national level, the racial diversity of an area positively correlates with the amount of property taken by law enforcement through forfeiture. (This doesn’t alone prove race is the cause of that increase.)

While some of Ocasio-Cortez’s woke rhetoric may be a bit over the top, Republicans who believe in property rights and due process still ought to work with her on this issue, if she is willing. Conservative lawmakers such as Sens. Rand Paul and Mike Lee have introduced legislation to combat this harmful practice. More elected officials from both parties should join these bipartisan efforts.

As rare as it is, AOC is right about this one. Our civil asset forfeiture system is unfair, un-American, and ripe for reform.

Additional Reading:
Amazing Civil Asset Forfeiture WIN! (Steve Lehto) | The Heat: US Civil Asset Forfeiture Controversy Part 2 | Data Privacy in the Data Center: A Guide to Compliance | Over $455,000 Seized from Medical Marijuana Patient Slapped with Civil Asset Forfeiture | The U.S. government has a massive, secret stockpile of bitcoin — Here’s what happens to it | AYS Civil Forfeiture | Here’s what happens to Russian oligarch yachts after they’re seized | Politician Victim of Civil Asset Forfeiture | Dallas K-9 Instrumental in Civil Forfeiture of $106,000 at Love Field Airport Despite There Being no Arrest or Crime | Ensuring Legal and Regulatory Compliance in Data Center Operations | Kim Kardashian and Floyd Mayweather sued by investors over alleged crypto scam | No Arrest — But Cops Took And Kept His $2,035 Anyway | Colocation vs. Cloud: Hybrid Approaches Gain Ground | Navigating Data Center Sustainability: Green Leases and Power Purchase Agreements | Mergers & Acquisitions in Data Centers: Legal Due Diligence & Deal Structuring | Police Seize Car, Drive 56,000 Miles, Sell It Without Charging Owners With a Crime | Data Center Litigation: When Clients & Operators Collide in Court | Hybrid Cloud Deployments in Data Centers: Balancing Security & Compliance | Special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation could turn a profit for the government, thanks to Paul Manafort’s asset forfeiture | John Oliver Explains Civil Forfeiture By Police | The government took $41,000 from this Texan at a Houston airport six months ago. They never gave it back. | Due Process in Civil Forfeiture: Are Property Owners’ Rights Protected? | Police seize property without charges and pocket the proceeds. There’s a bipartisan move to crack down. | Greenwashing vs. True Sustainability: Legal Pitfalls for Data Centers

You might also like:
Bank Account Freezes: Protecting Your Assets | Yes, the government can steal your stuff | DEA & TSA Take $82,000 Life Savings From Pittsburgh Retiree | Asset Forfeiture Defense Strategies | Michigan Enacts Civil Asset Forfeiture Reforms | Senator Mike Lee Asks Attorney General Nominee Barr About Civil Asset Forfeiture! | Real Estate Forfeiture Defense – Rucci Law | End Civil Forfeiture of assets Without A Court Order | Police agencies forfeit millions after new law chokes off funds from asset seizures | Inside Civil Asset Forfeiture | Due Process in Forfeiture Defense | Theft of Public Funds or Accounting Incompetence? Kansas Police Agencies Can’t Accurately Track Property Forfeitures | How to Avoid Asset Forfeiture in Oklahoma | America’s Asset-Forfeiture Scam Is Law Enforcement’s Disgrace | Civil asset forfeiture in South Carolina is unconstitutional, circuit court judge rules | Professional Tenant Rights Attorney Legal Services | The Justice Department just shut down a huge asset forfeiture program | Forfeiture for Money Transmitting Business | Two Ex-Federal Prosecutors Explain Asset Forfeiture | Paul Padda Podcast | Government Seizure Attorney California – Rucci Law | The government took $41,000 from this Texan at a Houston airport six months ago. They never gave it back. | Forfeiture Defense Strategies – Attorney Rucci | Property Forfeiture Attorney – Rucci Law | LA Times (6-09-21) FBI wants to keep the fortune in cash, gold, jewels from Beverly Hills raid. Is it abuse of power?