Asset Forfeiture Laws ‘Evil’ and ‘Unreformable,’ Say Former Justice Department Officials

Last week The Washington Post ran a series of in-depth articles on the problems with civil asset forfeiture. Today, two former justice department officials weighed in on the issue, calling for the abolition of the program they helped create.

John Yoder and Brad Cates were directors of the Justice Department’s Asset Forfeiture Office, with a combined tenure running from 1983 to 1989. As they explain, the program started off with good intentions, but has turned to be a cure worse than the disease:

Asset forfeiture was conceived as a way to cut into the profit motive that fuelled rampant drug trafficking by cartels and other criminal enterprises, in order to fight the social evils of drug dealing and abuse. Over time, however, the tactic has turned into an evil itself, with the corruption it engendered among government and law enforcement coming to clearly outweigh any benefits.

Can asset forfeiture be reformed? Yoder and Cates don’t think so:

The Asset Forfeiture Reform Act was enacted in 2000 to rein in abuses, but virtually nothing has changed. This is because civil forfeiture is fundamentally at odds with our judicial system and notions of fairness. It is unreformable.

Despite its popularity amongst law enforcement, civil asset forfeiture clearly violates key principles of the U.S. legal system. It reverses the burden of proof, and violates the principle that people are innocent until proven guilty.

This opposition from former government officials who helped implement it is a testament to the harm it causes. It’s just a shame that their opposition comes 20 years after their role in its implementation.

For more about civil asset forfeiture, see “How Cops Became Robbers,” by Reason’s Jacob Sullum.

Related Posts:
In appeals court hearing, judges criticize case of Phoenix police seizing man’s $39,500 | Civil Asset Forfeiture Triggers Excessive Fines Clause | Michigan Rolled Back Civil Asset Forfeiture Reform | Under the Microscope: Data Centers Face Local and State Regulatory Scrutiny | Fake Reform Won’t Fix Police Addiction To Forfeiture Cash | Indiana Man Fights Police Use of Civil Forfeiture to Take His Land Rover | Oregon Seizes $121,000 of Deceased Veteran’s Benefits | Bennis v. Michigan, Supreme Court OKs Civil Forfeiture | Warrant of arrest issued against seized funds from Bank of Saipan | Zoning & Permitting for Data Centers: Navigating Local Regulations | Smart PDUs & Data Center Power Management: Legal & Operational Insights | Data Privacy Laws Every Data Center Operator Should Know | Massachusetts Worst in Nation for Civil Forfeiture Laws | Government May Not Avoid Just Compensation in Debt Seizures | Middle District Of Florida U.S. Attorney’s Office Collects More Than $168 Million In Civil And Criminal Actions In Fiscal Year 2022 | Civil Asset Forfeiture is Worse Than We Thought (Steve Lehto) | Data Center Cost Optimization Strategies: Balancing OPEX, CAPEX, and Performance | Amazing Civil Asset Forfeiture WIN! (Steve Lehto) | Data Center Digital Twins: Contractual Obligations & IP Ownership | HB19: Reforming Civil Asset Forfeiture | Growth of Data Centers Likely Faces Economic, Legal Challenges | Optimizing Your Data Center Investment: Strategies for Success | How Asset Forfeiture Drives the Police State | A look into DHS asset forfeiture procedures

Related Posts:
Understanding Lienholder Roles in Forfeiture Cases | Civil asset forfeiture creates perverse incentives that can cost you your property. | Special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation could turn a profit for the government, thanks to Paul Manafort’s asset forfeiture | Avoid seizures of cash by taking prudent measures | Cops Taking Your Cash | Civil Forfeiture in America | No Arrest — But Cops Took And Kept His $2,035 Anyway | Attorney General Sessions Announcement on Asset Forfeiture | IRS Forfeiture & Seizures: Tax-Related Asset Recovery Defense | Sebastian Rucci – American Greed Episode 12 – Season 8 | Bank Account Freezes: Protecting Your Assets | Police Can Take Your Money Through Civil Forfeiture | DEA Asset Seizure – Rucci Law | Boston Cops Fleece Citizens to Secretly Buy Controversial Spy Tech | Civil Forfeiture Laws And The Continued Assault On Private Property | Legislation Introduced to Curb Federal Forfeiture | Class Action Against FBI For Abusive Seizure and CIVIL FORFEITURE! Viva & Barnes HIGHLIGHT! | Seizure of Medical Marijuana Assets: Legal Defense | Dallas Police Seized $100K In Cash From Love Field Traveler Using Civil Asset Forfeiture | Supreme Court Rules that Excessive Fines Clause Applies to States and Constrains Civil Asset Forfeiture | Warrant of arrest issued against seized funds from Bank of Saipan | FBI Seized Almost $1 Million From Family, Without Charges – FoxNews | Seizures of Bank Accounts | House Forfeiture Attorney California – Rucci Law | Sessions Creates DOJ Asset Forfeiture Watchdog